Why Do Marketing Vendors Blame Each Other When Results Are Weak?

TL;DR: Why do marketing vendors blame each other when results are weak?

Marketing vendors can blame each other because their work connects, but each is responsible only for the piece they were hired to deliver. Someone may bring visitors to a page that another vendor built. Weak overall results alone don’t tell you which piece fell short, and pointing at someone else’s work doesn’t prove a vendor did their own job well.

In This Article

Why Each Vendor Points at Someone Else

You’re paying for marketing, but the results aren’t what you hoped for. The social media person points at the website. The website person points at the visitors.

Meanwhile, you’ve got a crew to keep busy and a business to run.

What do those explanations actually tell you about the work you paid for? To sort that out, we need to separate how the pieces connect from what each vendor was hired to do.

Marketing vendors can blame each other because their work connects. Each can answer for their own assignment, but that assignment doesn’t necessarily cover everything between an advertisement and a customer inquiry.

As Nicole Crocker, CEO, SBMS Media, puts it: “Everything that they do is connected to one another and if one person isn’t managing the entire workflow and results, it can be hard to manage.”

That’s the tricky part. A vendor can finish their assigned piece while the overall result still disappoints you. But pointing at another piece doesn’t establish that their own work was done well.

Think about separate trades working on connected parts of a house. Their work meets, but their assignments aren’t interchangeable. You wouldn’t understand a problem just by hearing one trade name another.

We can look at marketing responsibility the same way. Keep the connected work in view without treating everyone involved as responsible for everything.

A vendor’s explanation of someone else’s work isn’t an answer about their own.

Back to top

How Marketing Pieces Connect to One Another

Picture a homeowner seeing your marketing while looking for help with a project. What they click may take them somewhere built by a different vendor than the person who created the post.

That’s why it helps to picture the path the homeowner takes. You don’t need to learn a pile of marketing terms to follow it.

A landing page is simply the page someone reaches after clicking. A funnel is the connected path meant to guide that visitor toward an action, such as requesting an estimate.

Neither term means the person sending visitors also built everything those visitors encounter. Sending someone to a destination and building that destination are different assignments.

Here’s a connected marketing path.

A homeowner sees a campaign post, clicks through to a landing page, goes through the estimate request steps, and receives a follow-up message.

That’s an illustration, not a required sequence or a description of your current setup.

In this example, a social media vendor might handle the post. A website vendor might build the destination, while an advertising vendor handles paid placements. Your vendors may divide the work differently, so check what each was actually hired to do.

As the owner, you’re looking at the whole path because you care about the business outcome. Each vendor is looking at the portion assigned to them. That difference helps explain why several answers about separate pieces may still leave your bigger question unanswered.

Keep each action separate as you listen. Getting someone to a page is one action; what they do after arriving is another. They’re connected, but they aren’t the same work.

Back to top

When Social Media Leads to Someone Else’s Funnel

Let’s say one marketer runs your social media campaign and another builds the destination. You want to know why the campaign isn’t producing the result you wanted, but each person is talking about a different part.

In this example, the social media vendor was hired to get people to a landing page. The other marketer built the path visitors encounter after arriving. The social media marketer answers for getting people there, not for what happens inside a funnel someone else built.

The assignment could also call for people to take an action on the social platform itself. If that’s what you hired the social media marketer to do, hold them to that action. A website visit isn’t automatically part of every social media assignment.

Here’s how that conversation might sound.

This is an illustration, not a real conversation or a finding about either vendor’s work.

Owner: The overall result isn’t what we wanted.

Social media vendor: My assignment is to bring people to the landing page. I didn’t build the steps they go through after arriving.

Funnel builder: My assignment is to build the page and convert the visitor into a lead that will convert to an appointment for the sales team.

Notice the turn. One person points forward to the destination, while the other points backward to the visitors. Neither statement, by itself, establishes what went wrong.

Read these statements as descriptions of where responsibility ends, not proof of who caused the problem. The social media assignment doesn’t grow because the next step disappointed you. And the funnel builder’s concern about visitors doesn’t prove the social media work fell short.

That distinction helps you keep a frustrating conversation fair without letting either vendor’s own work disappear from the discussion.

Back to top

What Each Vendor Can Answer For

A job title can sound like it covers more than it does. Before asking someone to explain your whole marketing result, bring the conversation back to what you hired that person to deliver.

Each vendor can be held to their assigned piece, and no further. That doesn’t mean you can’t ask direct questions. It means those questions need to match the work they own.

Ask what the vendor was hired to produce or run. Then keep your questions tied to that assignment. We’re talking about how to keep the conversation focused, not a test that proves someone did a good job.

These are examples, not fixed job descriptions.

A social media vendor might be hired to bring people to a destination. A website vendor might be hired to build it. An advertising vendor might be hired to run the ad campaign.

Your agreements may divide that work differently. Use the actual assignment rather than assuming the title tells the whole story.

Building a page isn’t the same job as bringing visitors to it. Running an advertisement isn’t the same job as handling everything someone encounters after clicking.

At the same time, a limited assignment isn’t a pass on answering questions. Ask the social media vendor about their social media work. Ask the person who built the destination about that destination.

If the titles are adding to the confusion, understanding the difference between a marketing manager vs marketing agency can help you sort out the roles. For this conversation, though, keep coming back to the particular work you purchased.

You can recognize that the work connects without making every vendor responsible for every piece.

Back to top

Why One Channel Cannot Explain the Whole Result

You’ve heard what each vendor worked on. Now there’s another question: how much did that work contribute to the overall result?

A channel is a way your marketing reaches people, such as social media or paid advertising. Figuring out a channel’s contribution is different from identifying who built a page or ran a campaign.

Funnel’s study addresses that measurement difficulty. The source is a Funnel and Ravn Research study, reported by PPC Land.

In a study of 238 in-house and agency marketing leaders by Funnel and Ravn Research, reported by PPC Land, 86% of in-house marketers and 79% of agency marketers said they struggle to determine the impact of each marketing channel on overall performance.

That finding has limits. It describes difficulty working out each channel’s impact. It doesn’t establish that your vendor failed, that another succeeded, or that anyone’s explanation of your results is correct.

Here’s the distinction to carry into your conversation: a statement about one channel isn’t automatically an explanation of the whole connected path. That’s a reasoning point, not a finding from the study. Treat the statement as being about that channel unless the speaker has support for saying more.

And keep asking about assigned work. Difficulty measuring a channel’s impact isn’t a reason to set those questions aside.

For your business, both questions matter. What did the vendor deliver, and how much did that channel contribute? An answer to one doesn’t automatically settle the other.

Back to top

What Vendor Blame Statements Actually Tell You

It can be hard to stay focused when an explanation keeps coming back to someone else’s work. We can make that conversation easier to follow by separating what the speaker knows about their own assignment from what they’re saying about another person’s.

The examples here show that distinction. They aren’t claims about what vendors usually say or proof that any particular explanation is right.

When someone points at the destination.

A social media vendor says their assignment ends when someone reaches the landing page. That describes where their responsibility ends. Ask about the work they did to bring people there, rather than asking them to answer for a destination someone else built.

When someone points at the visitors.

The person who built the destination questions the visitors arriving from the campaign. That’s a statement about another part of the path, not proof about it. Keep your questions to that vendor focused on the destination they were hired to build.

When you’re looking at the overall result.

You say the campaign hasn’t delivered the business outcome you wanted. That concern deserves a direct discussion. Still, the disappointment alone doesn’t identify which assigned piece fell short.

You don’t have to soften your concern or pretend the result doesn’t matter. Keep your questions neutral and specific so the conversation stays on work the speaker can answer for.

Try these questions in the conversation.

What part of this campaign were you hired to deliver?

Where does your responsibility for that work end?

Which part of your explanation is about the work you delivered?

Which part is about another vendor’s work rather than your own?

These questions won’t diagnose the entire campaign. Their purpose is narrower: helping you understand what each person can answer for without turning a comment about connected work into an unsupported accusation.

Ask for an answer about their assignment, not a defense of someone else’s.

Back to top

Questions About Marketing Vendor Responsibility

You may understand the separate assignments and still feel unsure about what to say next. These questions cover a few places where that conversation can get tangled.

How do I ask about weak marketing without accusing anyone?

Describe the result that concerns you, then ask about the vendor’s assigned work. You might say, “I’m disappointed with the overall result, and I want to understand the part you handled.” That keeps your concern on the table without deciding in advance who caused it. You can be direct about your business needs and fair about responsibility at the same time.

What if a vendor uses the word funnel differently?

Ask them to describe the actual pages and actions they mean. The label alone doesn’t tell you where their assignment starts or stops. For example, ask whether they’re talking about the page visitors reach or the steps visitors take afterward. Bring the discussion back to the work they were hired to perform, rather than debating the term.

Can I ask about the whole campaign during a vendor conversation?

Yes, you can discuss the overall result while keeping responsibility tied to each vendor’s assignment. Explaining your concern isn’t the same as making that vendor answer for everything. Make that distinction plain when you speak. You might say, “The whole result concerns me, but right now I’m asking about the piece you handled.”

Should I ignore a vendor’s concern about another vendor?

No, you can listen without treating the concern as proven. A comment about connected work may help you understand what the speaker is referring to. It doesn’t establish the quality of either person’s work on its own. Keep that comment separate from the vendor’s answer about what they themselves delivered.

What if two vendors use similar job titles?

Compare their actual assignments rather than relying on their titles. Similar titles don’t tell you whether the vendors were hired to do the same work. Ask each person to describe the piece they were hired to deliver. That gives you a more useful basis for your questions than the name of the role alone.

Back to top

Keep the Conversation About the Work

You deserve direct answers about the marketing you purchased. You don’t need to become a marketing expert to ask what someone was hired to do and hear an explanation of that work.

Keep your questions tied to each vendor’s assignment. If the answer shifts toward someone else, bring the conversation back to the speaker’s own work. Your concern about the overall result still matters, even when responsibility is divided.

If you’re considering help from SBMS Media, start with the kind of support your business needs. Read about the full scope of a part-time marketing manager’s role and weigh our reviews on Google alongside those needs as you decide whether we’re a fit.

Talk with SBMS Media about our fractional CMO and part-time marketing director services if you want help understanding your marketing needs.

Back to top

Picture of Nicole Crocker

Nicole Crocker

Nicole Crocker has 30 years of experience in sales, marketing, and advertising within the construction industry. She co-founded a home improvement company with her husband that scaled to 8-figures and produced a remodeling-focused TV series that aired on Fox 5 San Diego for two years. Committed to supporting visionary entrepreneurs, Nicole now channels her expertise into providing affordable, strategic single-source marketing solutions through her boutique marketing agency, empowering businesses in the construction industry to reach their full potential.