TL;DR: What should every marketing vendor report each month?
Every marketing vendor should report numbers that fit its campaign and platform, plus relevant new products, features and industry news. Digital and print campaigns need different measures. A report that never arrives is a warning sign: it typically means no ongoing campaign adjustments, no established work instructions and no consistency in growth with that vendor.
In This Article
- Why monthly reports differ by marketing vendor
- What a digital marketing vendor should report
- What a print marketing vendor should report
- What your vendor should explain besides the numbers
- What a missing marketing report tells you
- How to ask a vendor for a monthly report
- Questions contractors ask about monthly vendor reports
- Get help setting vendor reporting expectations
Why monthly reports differ by marketing vendor
As Nicole Crocker, CEO, SBMS Media, puts it: “It depends on the campaign that you’re running and the platform that you’re running it on.” Start with the work you hired the vendor to do. Don’t expect every report to look alike.
A digital ad campaign and a printed mailer are different jobs. You wouldn’t judge a roofing crew and a plumbing crew by the same materials list. Marketing reports work the same way.
For digital ads, the report should show how the ads ran and how people responded. For print, it should show where the pieces were delivered and how many people scanned the code.
A different layout or a different set of numbers doesn’t make a report less useful. You’re trying to understand the work you’re paying for.
The basic expectation is simple: numbers that fit the campaign, a plain explanation of what’s new, and a report that actually arrives each month.
What a digital marketing vendor should report
For a digital campaign, expect six numbers: impressions, click-through rate, conversion rate, cost per impression, cost per lead and cost per sale. Your vendor should explain each one in plain words, not hand you a page of figures to sort out yourself.
Here’s what each number tells you. The figures below are made-up examples to show the math, not typical results.
- Impressions: how many times your ad was shown. One person can see it more than once, so 5,000 impressions doesn’t mean 5,000 people.
- Click-through rate: how often a showing of the ad turned into a click. Example: 5,000 impressions and 100 clicks is a 2% click-through rate.
- Conversion rate: how often a click turned into the action the campaign is built to get, such as a call or a form. Example: 100 clicks and 5 inquiries is a 5% conversion rate. Ask which action your vendor is counting.
- Cost per impression: what you paid for the ad to be shown. Ask whether the price is for one showing or for a set number of showings.
- Cost per lead: what you spent divided by the leads that came in. Example: $1,000 spent and 5 leads is $200 per lead. Ask what your vendor counts as a lead.
- Cost per sale: what you spent divided by the jobs you sold. Example: $1,000 spent and 2 sold jobs is $500 per sale.
Read the six numbers as steps on one path. The ad is shown. Someone clicks. That person calls or fills out a form. Some of those people become customers. Not every showing becomes a click, and not every inquiry becomes a sale.
A lead isn’t a sale. Someone asking about a repair isn’t the same as someone buying it. Both matter, but they tell you different things.
We want you to understand what each number answers. No single number explains the whole job.
What a print marketing vendor should report
A print campaign calls for three things: how many pieces were delivered, where they were delivered, and how many people scanned the QR code. That’s the square code someone scans with a phone.
These numbers answer different questions than digital ad numbers, so a print report doesn’t need to look like a digital one.
Read delivery counts and locations together. The count tells you how many pieces went out. The location tells you where they went.
A total alone doesn’t tell you whether the pieces reached the neighborhoods you had in mind. If your company serves a particular area, ask the vendor to show you both.
Code scans show a response, not a sale. A scan tells you someone used the code on the printed piece. It doesn’t tell you that person became a lead or bought a job.
It’s the same idea as a click in a digital campaign. A scan and a sale are different things.
What your vendor should explain besides the numbers
Your vendor should explain relevant new products, features and industry news, not just send campaign numbers. Think of the vendor as your eyes and ears in the part of marketing it handles.
You’ve already got crews, customers and jobs to look after. You shouldn’t have to follow every platform announcement yourself.
Ask the vendor to put each update in everyday language and tell you what it means for the campaign you’re running. Two questions do most of the work:
“What changed, and does it apply to our campaign?”
“Is there anything for us to consider, or are you keeping us informed?”
Those questions separate useful guidance from a pile of forwarded announcements.
A new announcement isn’t automatically a reason to buy something. Give yourself room to understand it first.
You deserve an explanation of why an update matters, not just a notice that something changed.
What a missing marketing report tells you
A report that never arrives is a warning sign. It typically means three things are missing with that vendor:
- Nobody is making ongoing adjustments to your campaign.
- There are no established instructions for how the work gets done.
- There’s no consistency in growth, meaning growth you can count on.
Keep the word “typically” in mind. A missing report is a reason to ask about reporting directly. It doesn’t tell you everything that happened behind the scenes.
That matters when you’re already frustrated. You can be firm about the missing report without guessing why it wasn’t sent or treating it as proof of poor results.
Poor reporting is a common reason companies part ways with a vendor. In an ASK BOSCO and OnePoll survey of UK marketing managers, which surveyed 100 UK marketing managers who work or have worked with digital marketing agencies, 75% said they had dropped an agency over poor reporting.
If you’re considering a change, keep that decision separate from your first request for a report. Read when to replace a marketing vendor for that discussion.
How to ask a vendor for a monthly report
Put your reporting request in writing and tie it to the campaign that vendor handles. Keep it direct, polite and specific. You don’t need a stiff message or a long explanation of why you’re asking.
Use this monthly reporting request checklist.
- Name the campaign and platform, and agree on which of the numbers above apply.
- Send the request in writing so both sides can refer to it.
- Agree on a regular reporting date each month.
- Read each report for the campaign numbers and the explanation of what’s new.
An agreed date keeps both sides from having different ideas about when the report will arrive.
Here’s a message you can adapt.
Hi [vendor name], please send a monthly report for the campaign you’re handling for us.
Please include the measures that apply to the campaign and explain what each one counts. Please also explain any relevant new products, features or industry news.
Can we agree on a regular reporting date each month? Please confirm the date so we’re working from the same expectation.
Thanks, [owner name].
Keep this request focused on reporting. For the bigger job of coordinating several providers, see managing marketing vendors without becoming the project manager.
If the conversation turns into one provider blaming another, that’s a separate issue. Our article on why marketing vendors blame each other covers it. You don’t have to settle that disagreement before telling this vendor what report you expect.
Questions contractors ask about monthly vendor reports
Use these answers when a report leaves you unsure how to read it.
Can I compare conversion rates from different marketing vendors?
Only if both vendors are counting the same thing. One vendor may count phone calls and another may count form fills, and both will call the result a conversion rate. Ask each vendor what it counts before you put the numbers side by side. If they count different things, look at each rate within its own campaign instead of ranking the vendors.
What should I do if a marketing report has blanks?
Ask the vendor to explain each blank. Don’t read it as zero. A blank could mean the number wasn’t available, didn’t apply or was left out, and only the vendor can tell you which.
Should a new marketing feature mean more spending?
No. Learning about a new feature is separate from approving more spending. Ask the vendor why the feature matters to the campaign you already have. An update can be useful information without becoming a purchase.
Where can I find a full contractor marketing report checklist?
Use our separate guide to what a contractor’s marketing report should include. This article covers what each vendor should send based on its campaign and platform. That guide covers the full report.
Get help setting vendor reporting expectations
Start with the work you’re paying for and ask for an explanation you can understand. You don’t have to become a marketing specialist to have that conversation.
Your questions don’t need to sound technical to be useful. Asking what a number counts, why an update matters or when the report will arrive keeps the discussion tied to your business.
If you’d like help handling that responsibility, SBMS Media can help you set reporting expectations and oversee your marketing vendors. As you decide whether we’re the right partner for your business, consider our reviews on Google alongside the support you’re looking for.
Get help setting reporting expectations and overseeing your marketing vendors with SBMS Media’s fractional CMO services for contractors.
